Gears of War: Reloaded
PCGamesN
Gears of War Reloaded review - a compromised update of a classic shooter
Published 8/26/2025
Text · Full review
Score
60
-17 vs game avg
Review
Read originalCritic Atlas
Making subjectivity useful.
Reviewer profile
Reid McCarter
Current outlet: PCGamesN
Previously at: CGMagazine · Game Informer
Reviews
26
26 games · 26 scored
Avg score
70
26 scored reviews
Score style
Harsh
-5 vs peer avg · 26 compared
Outlets
3
CGMagazine · Game Informer · PCGamesN
Latest
2025
Most recent saved review
Reviewer scoring style
This reviewer currently scores about -5 points below the peer average on games where Critic Atlas has comparable scored reviews.
How to use this
A lower-than-peer score from this reviewer may be part of their normal baseline. Their positive reviews may be especially worth noticing.
Based on 26 compared reviews against other scored reviews for the same games.
Review history
How this reviewer maps across games
Review history follows the reviewer as a person, even if they have moved between outlets. Each review keeps the outlet where it was originally published.
Showing 1-26 of 26 reviews
The Precinct
PCGamesN
The Precinct review - a criminally dull police simulator
Published 5/13/2025
Text · Full review
Score
40
-26 vs game avg
Review
Read originalKarma: The Dark World
PCGamesN
Karma The Dark World review - a sci-fi horror bogged down by references
Published 4/18/2025
Text · Full review
Score
40
-29 vs game avg
Review
Read originalAssassin's Creed Shadows
PCGamesN
Assassin's Creed Shadows review - new ideas drowned in repetition and flat drama
Published 3/19/2025
Text · Full review
Verified original outlet page. Page exposes an updated date of 2025-03-19; reviewed platform was not clearly exposed in the page text, so platform_reviewed is left blank.
Action adventureOpen worldStealthSamuraiShinobiFeudal JapanUbisoft QuebecRepetition criticism
Score
60
-21 vs game avg
Mixed
Read originalBroken Roads
PCGamesN
Broken Roads review – a Fallout-inspired RPG flop
Published 4/10/2024
Text · Full review
Score
40
-25 vs game avg
Review
Read originalCall of Duty: Modern Warfare II
Game Informer
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare II Review - Wide Of The Mark - Game Informer
Published 11/1/2022
Text · Full review
Score
65
-10 vs game avg
Review
Read originalGears of War: Ultimate Windows 10 Edition
CGMagazine
Gears of War: Ultimate Edition (PC) Review
Published 3/1/2016
Text · Full review
Score
80
+10 vs game avg
Review
Read originalRise of the Tomb Raider (PC)
CGMagazine
Rise of the Tomb Raider (PC) Review
Published 2/17/2016
Text · Full review
Score
75
-10 vs game avg
Review
Read originalScore
80
-6 vs game avg
Review
Read originalScore
70
+10 vs game avg
Review
Read originalLife is Strange: Episode 5 - Polarized
CGMagazine
CGMagazine Life is Strange: Episode 5 - Polarized Review
Published 10/26/2015
Text · Full review
Score
80
+4 vs game avg
Review
Read originalWasteland 2: Director's Cut
CGMagazine
CGMagazine Wasteland 2: Director's Cut Review
Published 10/13/2015
Text · Full review
Score
80
+1 vs game avg
Review
Read originalScore
60
-5 vs game avg
Review
Read originalEverybody's Gone to the Rapture
CGMagazine
CGMagazine Everybody's Gone to the Rapture Review
Published 8/14/2015
Text · Full review
Score
90
+11 vs game avg
Review
Read originalKing's Quest - Chapter 1: A Knight to Remember
CGMagazine
CGMagazine King's Quest - Chapter 1: A Knight to Remember Review
Published 7/30/2015
Text · Full review
Score
80
-2 vs game avg
Review
Read originalLife is Strange: Episode 4 - Dark Room
CGMagazine
CGMagazine Life is Strange: Episode 4 - Dark Room Review
Published 7/30/2015
Text · Full review
Score
70
-7 vs game avg
Review
Read originalScore
50
-13 vs game avg
Review
Read originalScore
90
+10 vs game avg
Review
Read originalScore
50
-13 vs game avg
Review
Read originalLife is Strange: Episode 3 - Chaos Theory
CGMagazine
CGMagazine Life is Strange: Episode 3 - Chaos Theory Review
Published 5/20/2015
Text · Full review
Score
90
+12 vs game avg
Review
Read originalWolfenstein: The Old Blood
CGMagazine
CGMagazine Wolfenstein: The Old Blood Review
Published 5/10/2015
Text · Full review
Score
80
+5 vs game avg
Review
Read originalLife is Strange: Episode 2 - Out of Time
CGMagazine
CGMagazine Life is Strange: Episode 2 - Out of Time Review
Published 3/29/2015
Text · Full review
Score
90
+15 vs game avg
Review
Read originalHotline Miami 2: Wrong Number
CGMagazine
CGMagazine Hotline Miami 2: Wrong Number Review
Published 3/22/2015
Text · Full review
Score
60
-14 vs game avg
Review
Read originalLife is Strange: Episode 1 - Chrysalis
CGMagazine
Life Is Strange Ep1: Chrysalis (PS4) Review
Published 2/2/2015
Text · Full review
Score
80
-1 vs game avg
Review
Read originalResident Evil HD Remaster
CGMagazine
CGMagazine Resident Evil HD Remaster Review
Published 1/19/2015
Text · Full review
Score
70
-10 vs game avg
Review
Read originalState of Decay: Year One Survival Edition
CGMagazine
CGMagazine State of Decay: Year One Survival Edition Review
Published 11/12/2013
Text · Full review
Score
80
+7 vs game avg
Review
Read original