But Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Moomintroll: Winter’s Warmth’ Is Filled With Emotional Depth
Published 5/12/2026
Text · Full review
Score
85
+1 vs game avg
Review
Read originalMaking subjectivity useful.
Reviewer profile
Current outlet: But Why Tho?
Previously at: MMORPG.com
Reviews
29
29 games · 29 scored
Avg score
82
29 scored reviews
Score style
Lenient
+7 vs peer avg · 29 compared
Outlets
2
But Why Tho? · MMORPG.com
Latest
2026
Most recent saved review
This reviewer currently scores about +7 points above the peer average on games where Critic Atlas has comparable scored reviews.
How to use this
A higher-than-peer score from this reviewer may be less meaningful by itself. Look for cases where they are unusually high or low compared with their own baseline.
Based on 29 compared reviews against other scored reviews for the same games.
Review history
Review history follows the reviewer as a person, even if they have moved between outlets. Each review keeps the outlet where it was originally published.
Showing 1-29 of 29 reviews
But Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Moomintroll: Winter’s Warmth’ Is Filled With Emotional Depth
Published 5/12/2026
Text · Full review
Score
85
+1 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Directive 8020’ Captures Sci-Fi Horror Perfectly
Published 5/11/2026
Text · Full review
Score
95
+21 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Mixtape’ Embraces Cinema To Capture Emotion
Published 5/7/2026
Text · Full review
Score
80
-5 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Aphelion’ Is One Of The Best Sci-Fi Stories In Any Medium
Published 4/28/2026
Text · Full review
Score
95
+28 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Crimson Desert’ Is Ambition That Pays Off
Published 3/18/2026
Text · Full review
Score
90
+14 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘High on Life 2’ Is Comedy Gold Marred By Technical Difficulties
Published 2/18/2026
Text · Full review
Score
65
-7 vs game avg
Review
Read originalMMORPG.com
Review: ANNO 117: Pax Romana Is The Biggest The Franchise Has Ever Been.com
Published 11/10/2025
Text · Full review
Score
90
+7 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
EARLY ACCESS REVIEW: ‘Path of Exile 2’ Is Game Firing On All Cylinders
Published 12/6/2024
Text · Full review
Score
95
+7 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Bo: Path of the Teal Lotus’ Is A Gorgeous Folktale (PC)
Published 7/17/2024
Text · Full review
Score
85
+6 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘RKGK / Rakugaki’ Is Kinetic And Vibrant Vision (PC)
Published 5/27/2024
Text · Full review
Score
95
+18 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Venture To The Vile’ Is Whimsical Weirdness That Hits (PC)
Published 5/23/2024
Text · Full review
Score
85
+5 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Howl’ Crafts A Gorgeous Folk Tale (PC)
Published 1/28/2024
Text · Full review
Score
85
+5 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora’ Is Expansive And Beautiful (PC)
Published 12/6/2023
Text · Full review
Score
80
+8 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Cuisineer’ Serves Up A Stellar Game Loop (PC)
Published 11/7/2023
Text · Full review
Score
85
+7 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Decarnation’ Offers a Stellar Story Marred by Gameplay (Switch)
Published 6/6/2023
Text · Full review
Score
70
-1 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Atomic Heart’ Skips Too Many Beats
Published 2/20/2023
Text · Full review
Score
65
-6 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Kukoos: Lost Pets’ Is A Good Family Game (Switch)
Published 12/6/2022
Text · Full review
Score
85
+16 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Bayonetta 3’ is Pure Absurd Joy (Switch)
Published 11/1/2022
Text · Full review
Score
85
+1 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: Roller Champions is Fun Because its Free (PC)
Published 5/25/2022
Text · Full review
Score
65
+6 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: Starkiller isn’t Enough in ‘Star Wars: The Force Unleashed’ (Switch)
Published 4/20/2022
Text · Full review
Score
50
-14 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Aztech Forgotten Gods’ Is a Great Experience Even With Its Stumbles (XSX)
Published 3/9/2022
Text · Full review
Score
75
+17 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Days Gone’ is a Great Port if You Use a Controller(PC)
Published 5/18/2021
Text · Full review
Score
80
+10 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Iris.Fall’ Offers a Beautiful and Melancholic World (Switch)
Published 1/6/2021
Text · Full review
Score
80
+6 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Monster Prom 2: Monster Camp’ is the Relationship We Need in 2020
Published 10/28/2020
Text · Full review
Score
90
+5 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Parkasaurus’ is a Treat for New Sim Players and Veterans Alike
Published 8/17/2020
Text · Full review
Score
90
+9 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘A Fold Apart’ is an Emotional Puzzle
Published 4/17/2020
Text · Full review
Score
80
+4 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘LUNA: The Shadow Dust’ Offers Up Creative Puzzles and Beautiful Animation
Published 2/13/2020
Text · Full review
Score
100
+29 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘The Wanderer: Frankenstein’s Creature’ is an Emotional Experience
Published 11/3/2019
Text · Full review
Score
70
-9 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBut Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Call of Duty: Modern Warfare’ Campaign is a Return to Form for the Franchise
Published 10/30/2019
Text · Full review
Score
80
+2 vs game avg
Review
Read original