Critic Atlas
Log inSign up

Reviewer profile

Justin McElroy

Current outlet: Polygon

Reviews

21

21 games · 21 scored

Avg score

65

21 scored reviews

Score style

Harsh

-8 vs peer avg · 21 compared

Outlets

1

Polygon

Latest

2017

Most recent saved review

Reviewer scoring style

This reviewer currently scores about -8 points below the peer average on games where Critic Atlas has comparable scored reviews.

How to use this

A lower-than-peer score from this reviewer may be part of their normal baseline. Their positive reviews may be especially worth noticing.

Based on 21 compared reviews against other scored reviews for the same games.

Review history

How this reviewer maps across games

Review history follows the reviewer as a person, even if they have moved between outlets. Each review keeps the outlet where it was originally published.

Showing 1-21 of 21 reviews

Agents of Mayhem

Polygon

Agents of Mayhem review

Published 8/15/2017

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

55

-11 vs game avg

Review

Read original
RiME

Polygon

Rime review - Polygonclockmenumore-arrowpoly-lt-wire-logo

Published 5/25/2017

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

65

-14 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Night in the Woods

Polygon

Night in the Woods review - Polygonclockmenumore-arrow

Published 3/3/2017

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

75

-12 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Abzu

Polygon

Abzu review | Polygon

Published 8/2/2016

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

75

-6 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Quadrilateral Cowboy

Polygon

Quadrilateral Cowboy review | Polygon

Published 7/25/2016

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

80

-3 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Ghostbusters

Polygon

Ghostbusters (2016) review | Polygon

Published 7/12/2016

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

20

-17 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Shadow of the Beast

Polygon

Shadow of the Beast review | Polygon

Published 5/16/2016

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

30

-38 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Kathy Rain

Polygon

Kathy Rain review | Polygon

Published 5/10/2016

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

65

-17 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Severed

Polygon

Severed review | Polygon

Published 4/26/2016

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

90

+6 vs game avg

Review

Read original
ADR1FT

Polygon

Adrift review | Polygon

Published 3/31/2016

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

65

+3 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Far Cry Primal

Polygon

Far Cry Primal review | Polygon

Published 2/22/2016

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

85

+8 vs game avg

Review

Read original
The Witness

Polygon

The Witness review | Polygon

Published 1/25/2016

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

80

-7 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Transformers: Devastation

Polygon

Polygon Transformers: Devastation Review

Published 10/8/2015

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

65

-11 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Batman: Arkham Knight

Polygon

Polygon Batman: Arkham Knight Review

Published 6/18/2015

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

100

+18 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Chroma Squad

Polygon

Polygon Chroma Squad Review

Published 5/18/2015

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

75

+2 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Wolfenstein: The Old Blood

Polygon

Polygon Wolfenstein: The Old Blood Review

Published 5/5/2015

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

70

-5 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Code Name S.T.E.A.M.

Polygon

Code Name: STEAM review: off the rails | Polygon

Published 3/14/2015

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

35

-30 vs game avg

Review

Read original
The Order: 1886

Polygon

Polygon The Order: 1886 Review

Published 2/18/2015

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

55

-5 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Saints Row: Gat Out of Hell

Polygon

Polygon Saints Row: Gat Out of Hell Review

Published 1/19/2015

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

60

-5 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Broken Age

Polygon

Polygon Broken Age Review

Published 1/14/2014

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

80

+8 vs game avg

Review

Read original