Thick as Thieves
But Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Thick As Thieves’ Promises Criminal Capers But Delivers Rote Repetition
Published 5/20/2026
Text · Full review
Score
55
-12 vs game avg
Review
Read originalCritic Atlas
Making subjectivity useful.
Reviewer profile
Eddie De Santiago
Current outlet: But Why Tho?
Reviews
14
14 games · 14 scored
Avg score
80
14 scored reviews
Score style
Balanced
+2 vs peer avg · 14 compared
Outlets
1
But Why Tho?
Latest
2026
Most recent saved review
Reviewer scoring style
This reviewer currently scores close to the peer average on comparable games, with an average delta of +2.
How to use this
Their scores are not strongly harsh or lenient in the current data, so individual game deltas may be more useful than the overall style label.
Based on 14 compared reviews against other scored reviews for the same games.
Review history
How this reviewer maps across games
Review history follows the reviewer as a person, even if they have moved between outlets. Each review keeps the outlet where it was originally published.
Showing 1-14 of 14 reviews
Tides Of Tomorrow
But Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Tides of Tomorrow’ Lets You Shape the Narrative For Yourself and Others
Published 4/22/2026
Text · Full review
Score
80
+1 vs game avg
Review
Read originalCode Vein II
But Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Code Vein II’ Has Fun And Challenge In Its DNA
Published 1/26/2026
Text · Full review
Score
90
+18 vs game avg
Review
Read originalELDEN RING NIGHTREIGN The Forsaken Hollows
But Why Tho?
DLC REVIEW: ‘Elden Ring Nightreign’ “The Forsaken Hollows” Is Just More To Love
Published 12/10/2025
Text · Full review
Score
85
+16 vs game avg
Review
Read originalEscape from Duckov
But Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Escape From Duckov’ Provides Occasional Excitement And Not Much Else
Published 10/16/2025
Text · Full review
Score
65
-12 vs game avg
Review
Read originalGrounded 2
But Why Tho?
EARLY ACCESS REVIEW: ‘Grounded 2’ Is Bigger, Buggier, And Better
Published 7/29/2025
Text · Full review
Score
85
+7 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBlue Prince
But Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Blue Prince’ Provides a Solid Foundation And Engaging Mysteries
Published 4/12/2025
Text · Full review
Score
85
-6 vs game avg
Review
Read originalCitizen Sleeper 2: Starward Vector
But Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Citizen Sleeper 2: Starward Vector’ Finds Hope In A Loveless Place (PC)
Published 1/29/2025
Text · Full review
Score
90
+2 vs game avg
Review
Read originalBandle Tale: A League of Legends Story
But Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Bandle Tale: A League of Legends Story’ Turns Cutesy Crafting Into Hobby Hyperfixation (PC)
Published 2/20/2024
Text · Full review
Score
85
+11 vs game avg
Review
Read originalDisney Dreamlight Valley: A Rift in Time
But Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Disney Dreamlight Valley: A Rift in Time’ Provides More Disney Magic (PC)
Published 12/8/2023
Text · Full review
Score
85
+2 vs game avg
Review
Read originalCobalt Core
But Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘Cobalt Core’ Lets You Play Your Way (PC)
Published 11/8/2023
Text · Full review
Score
90
+1 vs game avg
Review
Read originalForspoken: In Tanta We Trust
But Why Tho?
DLC REVIEW: ‘Forspoken: In Tanta We Trust’ is a Short but Very Sweet Adventure (PS5)
Published 5/26/2023
Text · Full review
Score
85
+13 vs game avg
Review
Read originalAtelier Ryza 3: Alchemist of the End & the Secret Key
But Why Tho?
Review: ‘Atelier Ryza 3: Alchemist Of The End And The Secret Key’ Is An Unabashed, Shining Gem (Switch)
Published 3/23/2023
Text · Full review
Score
80
-2 vs game avg
Review
Read originalDIG - Deep In Galaxies
But Why Tho?
REVIEW: ‘DIG – Deep in Galaxies’—A Galaxy Of Content, A Planetoid of Depth (PC)
Published 3/7/2023
Text · Full review
Score
55
-8 vs game avg
Review
Read original