Critic Atlas
Log inSign up

Reviewer profile

Andrew McMahon

Current outlet: Shacknews

Previously at: GameSpot · IGN · PCGamesN · Twinfinite

Reviews

42

41 games · 42 scored

Avg score

67

42 scored reviews

Score style

Harsh

-8 vs peer avg · 42 compared

Outlets

5

GameSpot · IGN · PCGamesN · Shacknews · Twinfinite

Latest

2025

Most recent saved review

Reviewer scoring style

This reviewer currently scores about -8 points below the peer average on games where Critic Atlas has comparable scored reviews.

How to use this

A lower-than-peer score from this reviewer may be part of their normal baseline. Their positive reviews may be especially worth noticing.

Based on 42 compared reviews against other scored reviews for the same games.

Review history

How this reviewer maps across games

Review history follows the reviewer as a person, even if they have moved between outlets. Each review keeps the outlet where it was originally published.

Showing 1-42 of 42 reviews

EA Sports FC 26

Shacknews

EA Sports FC 26 review: Overcoming FIFA fatigue

Published 10/4/2025

Text · Full review

Score

80

+2 vs game avg

Review

Read original
EA Sports FC 25

Shacknews

EA Sports FC 25 review: Not an ideal role model

Published 9/24/2024

Text · Full review

Score

60

-10 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Capes

PCGamesN

Capes review - XCOM with superheroes and tricky turn-based tactics

Published 5/24/2024

Text · Full review

Score

60

-13 vs game avg

Review

Read original
EA Sports FC 24

IGN

EA Sports FC 24 for Switch Review

Published 10/4/2023

Text · Full review

Reviewer assigned from OpenCritic API author data during automated unresolved-reviewer resolver.

Score

40

-35 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Have a Nice Death

Twinfinite

Have a Nice Death Review - Death Is Its Own Reward

Published 3/16/2023

Text · Full review

Score

100

+20 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Choo-Choo Charles

Twinfinite

Choo Choo Charles Review - An Eight-Legged Trainwreck

Published 12/9/2022

Text · Full review

Score

30

-28 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Cult of the Lamb

Twinfinite

Cult of the Lamb Review - Can't Help But Drink the Kool-Aid

Published 8/10/2022

Text · Full review

Score

100

+15 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Hindsight

Twinfinite

Hindsight Review - A Matter of Perspective

Published 8/3/2022

Text · Full review

Score

70

-4 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Rune Factory 5

Twinfinite

Rune Factory 5 Review - Might Need Another Decade

Published 3/22/2022

Text · Full review

Score

60

-10 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Chernobylite

Twinfinite

Chernobylite Review - Radioactive Rogue-Lite Robbery

Published 8/5/2021

Text · Full review

Score

70

-4 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Gods Will Fall

Twinfinite

Gods Will Fall Review - Falling Short

Published 1/28/2021

Text · Full review

Score

60

-4 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Disc Room

Twinfinite

Disc Room Review - Bullet Hell Meets Puzzles

Published 10/29/2020

Text · Full review

Score

80

-4 vs game avg

Review

Read original
NHL 21

Twinfinite

NHL 21 Review - Line Change, Please

Published 10/20/2020

Text · Full review

Score

70

-5 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Battletoads

Twinfinite

Battletoads Review: Why Yes, We Do Have Battletoads

Published 8/19/2020

Text · Full review

Score

70

-2 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Desperados III

Twinfinite

Desperados III Review - All Good, No Bad or Ugly

Published 7/2/2020

Text · Full review

Score

80

-4 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Phoenix Point

Twinfinite

Phoenix Point Review - Engrossing Lovecraftian Strategy

Published 12/5/2019

Text · Full review

Score

80

+7 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Afterparty

Twinfinite

Afterparty Review - A Drunken Dance with the Devil

Published 10/28/2019

Text · Full review

Score

70

-3 vs game avg

Review

Read original
Killer Queen Black

Twinfinite

Killer Queen Black Review - A Snail of a Good Time

Published 10/10/2019

Text · Full review

Score

80

0 vs game avg

Review

Read original
The Surge 2

Twinfinite

The Surge 2 Review - A Gory Grind

Published 9/23/2019

Text · Full review

Score

70

-6 vs game avg

Review

Read original
NBA 2K20

Twinfinite

NBA 2K20 Review - A Safe Layup

Published 9/12/2019

Text · Full review

Score

60

-14 vs game avg

Review

Read original